We offer a vehicle Collection & Delivery Service - Contact us to hear more about how we can help!

General

My Gearbox Is Making Noises, Should I Be Worried?

May 21, 2020 · Hayley

My Gearbox Is Making Noises, Should I Be Worried?

In short: yes, a new or changing gearbox noise is worth checking. Whining and humming usually point to bearings, gear wear or low fluid. Grinding points to worn internals or a clutch or synchromesh problem. Clunking can come from the gearbox or the parts around it. Most noises start quietly and get louder, so an early check is cheaper. If the noise is loud, comes with slipping, a burning smell or a warning light, stop driving and speak to a specialist.

Gearboxes are built to run quietly, so a noise that was not there before is the car telling you something. The type, the timing and what the car is doing when you hear it all help narrow down the cause.

Gearbox noises and what they usually mean

The noiseLikely causeHow urgentWhat to do
Whining or humming that changes with road speedWorn bearings, gear wear or low or degraded fluidBook a check soonDo not ignore it, as wear usually gets worse
Grinding when changing gearWorn synchromesh or clutch problem (manual), worn internals or low fluid (automatic)UrgentStop driving and have it inspected
Constant grinding or rumblingFailing bearings or damaged gearsUrgentStop driving, as damage spreads quickly
Clunk when engaging Drive, Reverse or changing gearGearbox mounts, driveshafts, differential or worn gearbox partsBook a check soonNote when it happens (pulling away, lifting off, changing gear)
Rattle or clickingLoose parts, clutch or flywheel wear, bearings or low fluidBook a check soonNote if it changes in neutral
Slamming or banging into gearValve body, solenoid or clutch fault (automatic), clutch problem (manual)UrgentAvoid driving hard and have it diagnosed
Droning that rises with speedCommon on some CVTs, but can also mean wearBook a check soonSee our CVT guide below

Gearbox whine and hum

A whine that rises and falls with road speed is the classic sign of a worn bearing, worn gears or low fluid. It is often quiet at first and only noticeable in certain gears. Because it usually gets worse, it is best checked early.

Gearbox grinding noise

In a manual, grinding when you change gear often points to worn synchromesh or a clutch that is not fully releasing. In an automatic, grinding can mean worn internals or low fluid. Grinding all the time, or a rumble that does not change when you change gear, suggests failing bearings or damaged gears, and needs an urgent check.

Gearbox bearing noise

Worn bearings inside the gearbox typically cause a hum, whine or rumble that changes with speed or load. Bearings carry the shafts and gears, so a worn one lets them move out of position, which accelerates wear on everything else. This is one of the main reasons not to leave a whine.

Clunking and banging

A clunk when you move off, change gear or lift off the throttle can come from the gearbox itself, but also from engine and gearbox mounts, driveshafts, CV joints or the differential. A specialist can separate them on a road test and inspection. Harsh slamming into gear in an automatic is a different matter, as it often points to a valve body, solenoid or clutch fault.

Rattles and clicking

A rattle can be as simple as a loose heat shield, but it can also come from clutch or flywheel wear, bearings or low fluid. If the rattle changes when you put the car in neutral or press the clutch, tell the technician. It helps narrow things down.

Noises that are not always the gearbox

Several other parts make sounds that are easily mistaken for the gearbox:

  • Wheel bearings: hum or rumble that changes when you steer.
  • Driveshafts and CV joints: clicking when turning.
  • Clutch release bearing: noise that changes when you press the clutch pedal.
  • Engine and gearbox mounts: clunks when moving off or lifting off the throttle.
  • Differential: whine or clunk that changes on and off the throttle.
  • Exhaust and heat shields: rattles at certain speeds.

Gurgling noises usually come from the engine or cooling system, not the gearbox.

Noises on automatic, DCT and CVT gearboxes

The noise can differ with the type of gearbox. Many CVTs make some whine or drone, but a noise that gets louder is a warning sign. See our guide to common CVT gearbox problems. Dual-clutch gearboxes can be a little noisy at low speed, but new grinding, clunking or rattling is not normal. See our guide to common DCT issues and DSG gearbox problems.

How to describe the noise to a specialist

The more detail you can give, the quicker the diagnosis. Try to note:

  1. What it sounds like: whine, hum, grind, clunk, rattle or click.
  2. When it happens: cold or warm, pulling away, accelerating, coasting or braking.
  3. Which gear or speed: one gear, all gears, or only at certain speeds.
  4. Whether it changes in neutral: or when you press the clutch.
  5. Anything else: a warning light, slipping, a burning smell or a fluid leak.

Is it safe to drive with a noisy gearbox?

A faint, steady whine may not be an emergency, but it is a warning. Grinding, loud clunks, slipping, a burning smell, a fluid leak or a warning light are all reasons to stop. Continuing to drive can turn a repairable fault into a much larger one.

What happens when you bring it to us

  1. Listen and road test: we reproduce the noise and note when it happens.
  2. Fault code read and fluid check: where the gearbox allows.
  3. Inspection: to find out whether the noise is the gearbox or something nearby.
  4. Clear explanation: we explain what is wrong in plain English and what it needs, with no work before you approve it.

Gearbox noise FAQs

What causes noise in a gearbox?

The most common causes are worn bearings, worn gears, low or degraded fluid, and clutch or synchromesh problems. On automatics, valve body and solenoid faults can also cause noise or harsh engagement.

What does a bad gearbox sound like?

Typically a whine, hum, grind or clunk that is new or getting louder. It may come with slipping, difficulty changing gear, a burning smell or a warning light.

Why is my gearbox whining?

A whine that changes with road speed is usually worn bearings, worn gears or low fluid. It tends to get worse, so it is best checked early.

Why is my gearbox grinding?

In a manual it is often worn synchromesh or a clutch that is not releasing fully. In an automatic it can mean worn internals or low fluid. Grinding needs an urgent check.

Can low gearbox oil cause noise?

Yes. Low or degraded fluid reduces lubrication, which can cause whining, grinding and overheating. Do not keep driving if there is a leak.

Can I drive with a noisy gearbox?

A faint, steady noise may not be an emergency, but it is a warning. Grinding, loud clunks, slipping or a warning light are reasons to stop driving and get it checked.

Is a noisy gearbox expensive to fix?

It depends on the cause. Fluid or mount problems are usually far less than worn bearings or gears, and an early diagnosis helps avoid damage that makes it more expensive.

Talk to a gearbox specialist

Service4Service has 18 years’ experience diagnosing and repairing gearboxes, using OEM-approved parts and backed by a 12-month guarantee on qualifying repairs. Tell us what you are hearing and we will explain the likely cause and the next step. See our automatic gearbox repair services.

Call 0808 164 0418 (Monday to Friday, 8am to 5.30pm) or make an enquiry online.

Need a specialist?

Speak to a gearbox technician

Diagnostics from £150 +VAT. Nationwide collection available.

Make an Enquiry 0808 164 0418